Withdrawal of Deposit in RERA Appeal

Buyer Not Equal to Builder: High Court Allows Withdrawal of Deposit in RERA Appeal

In a significant ruling favouring homebuyers, the Bombay High Court held that a builder and buyer cannot be treated on equal footing, recognizing that buyers are generally in a more vulnerable position in real estate transactions.

—

Background of the Case

The case arose from a long-delayed real estate project where a homebuyer sought refund due to delay. The matter had reached the appellate stage under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016.

As per RERA provisions, a builder is required to make a pre-deposit before filing an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal.

In this case:

The builder deposited the required amount to pursue the appeal

The buyer sought permission to withdraw this deposited amount during the pendency of the appeal.


—

Key Issue Before the Court

Whether a homebuyer can withdraw the amount deposited by the builder during the pendency of the builder’s appeal before the RERA Appellate Tribunal.


—

High Court’s Observations

The Bombay High Court made crucial observations:

A homebuyer and builder are not equals in bargaining power

Buyers are often financially and legally vulnerable compared to developers

RERA provisions do not prevent the Appellate Tribunal from allowing withdrawal of deposited amounts in appropriate cases


The Court clarified that the tribunal has the discretion to permit withdrawal depending on the facts of each case.


—

Court’s Decision

The High Court upheld the order allowing the homebuyer to withdraw the amount deposited by the builder, even while the appeal was still pending.

The Court emphasized that such discretion should be exercised after considering:

The nature of the dispute

The delay in the project

The financial hardship faced by the buyer



—

Legal Significance

This ruling strengthens the protective framework of RERA by:

✔ Recognising Buyer Vulnerability

It acknowledges the unequal position of buyers compared to builders.

✔ Empowering Appellate Tribunals

Tribunals can allow withdrawal of deposited funds in deserving cases.

✔ Ensuring Practical Relief

Buyers do not have to wait indefinitely for relief while appeals are pending.


—

Conclusion

The Bombay High Court’s decision is a major boost for homebuyers, reaffirming that legal processes should not become a barrier to relief. By allowing withdrawal of deposited amounts, the Court ensured that buyers receive timely financial relief even during ongoing litigation.

More on 99888-17966