Plea in Supreme Court Alleges Bias in Senior Advocate Designations
A petition has been filed before the Supreme Court of India raising serious concerns over the process of designation of senior advocates by the Punjab and Haryana High Court.
—
Background of the Petition
The plea, filed by advocate Satish Chaudhary, challenges the High Court’s October 2025 list of newly designated senior advocates.
The petitioner alleges that despite fulfilling eligibility criteria and having over three decades of legal practice, his name was excluded from the final list.
—
Key Allegations
The petition raises important issues regarding:
⚖️ Lack of Transparency
The selection process is alleged to be opaque and lacking clear justification.
⚖️ Violation of Equality
It is argued that the process violates constitutional guarantees under Articles 14 and 21.
⚖️ Arbitrary Selection
The petitioner claims that:
He scored 50 out of 100 in evaluation
Several candidates with lower scores (37–46) were selected
His name was not even placed before the Full Court
—
Reliance on Supreme Court Guidelines
The petition relies on the landmark judgment in Indira Jaising v. Supreme Court of India, which laid down:
Objective and transparent selection criteria
Structured evaluation process
Emphasis on fairness and inclusivity
The petitioner contends that these guidelines were not properly followed.
—
What Happens Next?
The matter is scheduled to be heard by the Supreme Court, where the Court may examine:
Whether the High Court followed due process
Compliance with established guidelines
Scope of judicial review in designation matters
—
Legal Significance
This case could have wider implications:
✔ Reform in Designation Process
May lead to stricter transparency norms.
✔ Reinforcement of Judicial Standards
Ensures High Courts adhere to Supreme Court guidelines.
✔ Impact on Legal Profession
Could reshape how senior advocate designations are granted across India.
—
Conclusion
The petition highlights growing concerns about fairness and objectivity in senior advocate designations. As the Supreme Court takes up the matter, the outcome could significantly influence the credibility and transparency of the designation process in Indian courts.
—
If you want, I can also create:
✔ Short blog (SEO optimized)
✔ YouTube legal update script (30–60 sec)
✔ Featured blog image / thumbnail
✔ Carousel content for LinkedIn/Instagram
Just tell me 👍
Latest Legal News, Stories & Updates by LegalSeva 