In this post we’ll read about the decision of Punjab and Haryana high court which orders that male child cannot be separated from sister. Thus orders both children to stay with mother.

‘MALE CHILD CANNOT BE SEPARATED FROM SISTER’, SAYS PUNJABAND HARYANA HIGH COURT.

FACTS

As per the case, the woman (petitioner) got married to husband (respondent) on May 3, 2008. From the marriage, a male child was born on July 16, 2009 and a female child was born on March 13, 2017. The male child is presently about 11 and half years old and the girl is about 4-years-old. Meanwhile, their parents have separated since February 16, 2019.

The petitioner woman stated in her complaint that she has been thrown out and has not been permitted to take the children along with her, whereas the husband said that she had deserted the family.

After an Amicus Curiae appointed by the court to assess the best interests of the children submitted her report  it emerged that the children miss their mother’s company. The Amicus Curiae’s report also mentioned that the male child being older in age, is being indoctrinated against his mother. Despite the same, he is keen on meeting his mother and enjoys her company.

Child Custody Case Punjab Haryana High Court Chandigarh
Child Custody Case Punjab Haryana High Court Chandigarh

ALSO READ- ‘MALE CHILD CANNOT BE SEPARATED FROM SISTER’: HC GRANTS CUSTODY OF MINOR SIBLINGS TO MOTHER

The counsel for petitioner contended the girl child is below 5 years of age and Section 6 (a) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, stipulates that custody of such child should ordinarily be with the mother. The petitioner is working as a teacher and lives with her parents who are extremely affectionate. In such an environment, the children would blossom whereas in the company of their father and paternal grandparents they are withering, submitted the petitioner counsel.

ALSO READ- MOTHER CAN’T BE DENIED CHILD’S CUSTODY ON INFIDELITY ALLEGATIONS: HC

The respondent’s counsel, however, contended that the petitioner has pleaded that she does not possess any resources to maintain herself. Thus, custody of the children cannot be given to her as she would not be able to maintain them.

ALSO READ- MOTHER’S RIGHT TO CUSTODY OF MINOR CHILD HIGH COURT CHANDIGARH

The bench of Justice Mittal after hearing the contentions held, “The fact that she (petitioner) worked as a teacher for 10 long years suggests that she must have accumulated some savings and these can also be utilised for bringing up the children, at least on an interim basis. It is not disputed that she is residing with her parents and that they have a house in Mansa Devi Complex, Panchkula. The detailed report of the learned Amicus Curiae r conclude that the best interests of the children lie in the custody of their mother.”

ALSO READ- CUSTODY CASE IN HIGH COURT CHANDIGARH

LEGALPROVISIONS.

The girl child is under 5 years of age and in view of Section 6 (a) of the Minority Act, her best interests would definitely be served in the custody of the mother.

SECTION 6(a) of MINORITY AND GUARDIANSHIP ACT 1956 : provided that the custody of a minor who has not completed the age of five years shall ordinarily be with the mother;

ALSO READ- APPEAL UNDER GUARDIANS AND WARDS ACT 1890 FOR CUSTODY OF CHILD

LEGAL OPINION

The Punjab and Haryana High Court, while giving the custody of a male and female child to their mother, has opined that  “the male child cannot be separated from his sister as the same would traumatise both of them”.

The relationship of siblings are very pure and innocent, which is very extremely bounded at young age. Separating them at such a time leads to mental and psychological tension. Thus it’s very apt decision not to Separate.

ALSO READ- CUSTODY OF A CHILD IN NRI CASES

CONCLUSION

The bench of Justice Sudhir Mittal said, “Children are innocence personified. For their ideal development, it is essential that the period of innocence be cherished and protected. This, however, remains a pipe-dream where parents clash.

This post is written by Revathi Balakrishnan

For case specific advice, please contact best/top/expert Custody Lawyers Advocates in Chandigarh Panchkula Mohali Zirakpur Derabassi Kharar Baltana etc.

More on 99888-17966.

This post covers topics related to how to win child custody for fathers in india, child custody laws in india 2020, how to win child custody for mothers in india, custody of child under hindu law, custody of boy child in india, latest judgement on child custody to father, custody of child above 5 years, custody of girl child in india